| Quarterback | Team | Points |
| Kurt Warner | Slayers | 159 |
| Peyton Manning | Mob | 140 |
| Drew Bledsoe | Annihilators | 112 |
| Rich Gannon | Pirates | 95 |
| Mark Brunell | Nukes | 88 |
| Brett Favre | Blazers | 82 |
| Jeff George | Undertakers | 75 |
| Jon Kitna | Dogs | 73 |
| Troy Aikman | Shockers | 67 |
| Elvis Grbac | Rippers | 64 |
| Jeff Blake | Woodchucks | 61 |
| Brad Johnson | Americans | 60 |
| Tim Couch | Tee Shirts | 59 |
| Doug Flutie | Nukes | 57 |
| Randall Cunningham | Undertakers | 57 |
| Kordell Stewart | Americans | 46 |
| Dan Marino | Force | 41 |
| Damon Huard | Force | 29 |
| Steve McNair | Shockers | 28 |
| Neil O'Donnell | Force | 24 |
| Charile Batch | Dogs | 23 |
| Steve Young | Rippers | 18 |
| Steve Beuerlein | Annihilators | 17 |
| Jake Plummer | Tee Shirts | 14 |
| Shane Matthews | Woodchucks | 12 |
| Cade McNown | ----- | 11 |
| Doug Pederson | Woodchucks | 9 |
| Vinnie Testaverde | ----- | 5 |
| Stoney Case | ----- | 3 |
| Kent Graham | Undertakers | -1 |